In a common occurrence, you bend over to pick up the pencil you inadvertently dropped on the floor. Or you bend over to pick up the soap bar that has slipped through your fingers in the shower. Or ...View Article
You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser to improve your experience.
Synthetic vs.Bio-identical Replacement
Bio-identical Hormones: One Size Does Not Fit All!
Dr. Widenbaum prefers Bio-identical over synthetic hormones in most cases.
The severity of problems caused by the use of synthetic hormones led to a landmark decision in 2002 by the Women's Health Initiative (WHI), a long term health study of post-menopausal women.
After discovering that instances of breast cancer, heart disease and osteoporosis increased with the use of medroxy progesterone and pregnant mare's urine conjugated estrogens, research was halted.
Bio-identical hormones were brought into the spotlight after women sought a
safe alternative for synthetic hormone replacement therapy.
The difference between bio-identical and synthetic hormones starts at the molecular level. Bio-identical hormones have the same chemical structure as hormones made by the human body, and can replicate the actions of those made naturally.
Side effects and risk factors are minimized when your body recognizes its own molecular structure, fills its receptor cites efficiently, and can utilize, break down, and detoxify hormones effectively.
Bio-identical hormones can be tailored to match each individual's needs by a compounding pharmacist. Synthetic hormones, on the other hand, have an altered molecular structure that the body does not recognize completely, thus their actions are not straightforward and they are not detoxified from the body as easily.
Side effects are common with these types of hormones because they are foreign to the body. Synthetic hormones are prescribed as a "one size fits all", and cannot be specifically made for an individual.
The individualized approach of bio-identical hormone treatment requires a saliva hormone test. This will measure only active (free/unbound) hormone levels unlike serum tests, which reflect inactive (total/bound) levels.
Measuring inactive hormone levels is not useful in assessing function or balance. When testing the sex hormones through saliva, it is also important to assess adrenal status (DHEA and diurnal cortisols).
Even if the chief complaints seem to be an imbalance of the sex hormones, the adrenal and sex hormone pathways are so closely linked that an imbalance in one area will affect the function and efficiency of the other.
The state of the art delivery system for bio-identical hormones is transdermal.
By applying hormone to the skin rather than ingesting it, the liver first-pass is averted, thus therapeutic levels can be reached with far less hormone.
Studies have shown that measurement of transdermal hormones is best done through saliva rather than serum. Overdosing of hormone supplementation is often seen when using serum to monitor topical hormones (often 4-5 times higher than is needed).
A good starting place for assessing hormonal status is to measure estradiol, progesterone, testosterone, DHEA, and morning cortisol.
Remember: cortisol has a well established 24-hour diurnal rhythm, and the
time of day when this is measured will reveal unique aspects of one's health.
If there are complaints of sleep disruptions, a night cortisol should also be performed, and if there are suspected metabolic and blood sugar dysregulations, all cortisols should be tested (morning, noon, evening and night).
1. Peter O'leary, Peter Feddema, Katherine Chan, Mario Taranto, Margaret Smith, Sharon Evans (2000) Salivary, but not serum or urinary levels of progesterone are elevated after topical application of progesterone cream to pre-and postmenopausal women . Clinical Endocrinology 53 (5), 615-620.
2. Lee, John R. MD. Letters to the Editor Menopause. 10(4):374-377, July 2003
3. Mead, Jay H. MD. Saliva versus Serum Bibliography, Labrix Clinical Services, Inc. (2004)
4. FDA Statement on the Results of the Women's Health Initiative (8/13/2002) Women's Health Initiative (WHI) Results Signal Need for Reassessment of Risks and Benefits of Conjugated Equine Estrogens/medroxyprogesterone Acetate (Prempro) in Postmenopausal Women.
5. Risks and benefits of estrogen plus progestin in healthy postmenopausal women. JAMA 17 July 2002; 288:321-333
6. Diurnal changes of salivary estradiol in a female during luteal phase., IBL Hamburg Germany (2004)